Welcome to the third instalment of our series where Andy Bannister tackles common questions or objections to the Christian faith. This month: freedom
One of my favourite movies is Braveheart. Who could forget that stirring speech made by Mel Gibson, playing Scottish hero William Wallace, as he motivates his troops at the Battle of Stirling Bridge with the cry: “They may take our lives, but they can never take our freedom!”
Freedom is a powerful idea and probably our culture’s supreme value. People want to believe they are free to choose their ethics, beliefs, values, and more. Our culture proclaims that choice is good, the more of it the better, and anything that restricts it is bad. And that’s a problem when it comes to God – surely, the protest goes, God is anti-freedom. Don’t I have to choose between my personal autonomy and a belief in God?
Well, that depends how you define “freedom”. And defining it as “the absence of any constraints” is a bad way to begin, because no such version of freedom exists. For example, I want to be free to eat endless Cadbury’s Creme Eggs. I also want to be free to run a mile in six minutes. Those two desires conflict – I cannot choose them both and thus I am forced to decide which freedom is the most important and sacrifice accordingly.
This shows us something important: real freedom is not the absence of constraints but the right constraints. Furthermore, if I indulge my Creme Egg eating fixation, I will quickly discover my body has limits, as my waistline grows and my mile times drop. My choice has crashed into reality.
One of my hobbies is drone flying. The instructions that came with my eye-wateringly expensive flying camera warn about not flying it in enclosed spaces, such as woods. Over Christmas, I made the mistake of ignoring that constraint, took it flying in a nearby forest, and bounced it off a tree, almost destroying it. If we use something the wrong way, we can damage it. So, what about us as humans: what were we designed for? Fascinating question, isn’t it?
There’s yet a further problem with defining freedom as “personal autonomy”: it destroys relationships. To be in a relationship requires you to make commitments and to sacrifice certain freedoms. When I got married, 18 years ago, I discovered staying out late at the pub without telling my wife, or spending hundreds of pounds on new gadgets without talking to her first, did not go down well. Now I was in a new kind of relationship, that required giving up some freedom – but with that sacrifice came commitment and love and new kinds of freedoms.
But there is one last problem with playing off “freedom” against “God” and it’s that the objection overlooks something: namely that nobody is free because everybody is serving something. If it isn’t God, then it’ll be your career, or your grades, or your bank balance, or your sex life, or a particular hobby. As David Foster Wallace, the Pulitzer Prize nominated novelist remarked:
“In the day-to-day trenches of adult life, there is actually no such thing as atheism. There is no such thing as not worshipping. Everybody worships. The only choice we get is what to worship. And an outstanding reason for choosing some sort of God or spiritual-type thing to worship … is that pretty much anything else you worship will eat you alive.”
He goes on to unpack that idea by explaining that if you worship anything other than God, that thing will consume you. Worship your career, and you will work yourself to death; worship money and you will never feel you have enough; worship your intellect and you will always feel stupid.
Worship these other things, give up your freedom to them and they will crucify you inside with self-loathing. In contrast, at the heart of the Christian faith, Jesus was crucified for you.
If you follow Jesus, yes there will be constraints, but they will be the right constraints, the ones designed by a God who knows you and loves you. And a God who, in Jesus, made the first move, giving up his independence when he went to the cross, so that you may know the loving relationship for which you were intended. As Gal 5:1 puts it: “It is for freedom that Christ has set us free.”
I highly recommend Tim Keller’s new book, Making Sense of God, which explores this issue in more depth in chapter five (from which I have drawn some of the above). It’s a very helpful resource, either to give to unchurched friends to help them begin thinking about faith, or for Christians who want to think through what they believe and how to explain it.
Have you heard (or do you have) a question or issue you’d like Andy to explore in a future column? Email it to firstname.lastname@example.org.
To read or search stories in our other categories please choose from the following:-
'We kept on running until we felt safe'
Rwanda genocide survivor Beatrice Smith tells MANDY PILZ how God looked after her family when they were forced to flee for their lives ...
'My dad disowned me'
Mandy Pilz describes the impact of her troubled upbringing on her life and how learning to trust her heavenly Father has changed everything ...
Testimony: life hurts - but it hasn't stopped me living it
Dr Elizabeth McNaught has written a book to share her personal experience of anorexia – and give hope to others ...
Where is God in a world of suffering?
Dr Andy Bannister continues his series tackling common questions or objections to the Christian faith
Big interview: Pete Greig on talking to God
Why do we find it so difficult to talk to God? Pete Greig, founder of the 24-7 prayer movement, has some ideas ...
Lent: the gift of forgiveness
As we begin a new year, author AMY BOUCHER PYE invites you to embrace a gift that keeps on giving – forgiveness ...
Inspire Awards 2016: 'my recovery from drugs hell'
How ‘Recovery Champion’ Michelle Scott from Tyneside is showing her clients that change is possible ...
God and Santa - tackling a silly argument
Childish beliefs? ANDY BANNISTER on why a popular atheist taunt simply doesn’t add up …
Matt Redman: singing to the soul
Matt Redman’s worship anthem 10,000 Reasons has made an impact on people right across the world ...
'God must be amazing if he has people like Kathy on his side!'
What could be more devastating than finding out your child’s life is in danger? Mum Kerry relates how a hospital chaplain made all the difference ...
Christian Publishing & Outreach, registered in England & Wales (Charity no 221462).
Company limited by guarantee No 588731. VAT no 860 219 341.
Registered office: CPO, Garcia Estate, Canterbury Road, Worthing BN13 1BW, UK